I would be very surprised to see any of the freshman RS. I really only have the old, we need the depth argument - however it remains valid. An interesting dilemma though, is that a player may begin redshirting, and simply forfeits he ability to redshirt if he comes into a game. This means Eastman could sit out until injuries to Dodie and CRob, god forbid, knock on wood, throw salt over your shoulder, sideline them and we need JE in MVC-play. That being said, you sacrifice a lot of development that comes with gradual increase in PT the above scenario. I don't like the idea of redshirting a player unless it's to condition and/or bulk up as AT did two years ago.