Julian Betko transferred from Clemson to Butler and promptly tore an ACL, healed, tore the other, then played two moderately healthy seasons - one as q sixth year.
If DL is on target for a degree and especially if he has be grades to gain entrance to grad school; hed get the 6th year.
Julian Betko is an example of a guy who did get a 6th year waiver...
but I would beg to differ slightly since Betko's situation is not exactly the same...and some of the things you cite are debatable...
You say - he only played "TWO moderately healthy seasons" at Butler..
but not entirely accurate...
In 2005-2006 he played in every one of Butler's 33 games
In 2006-2007 he "set a Butler single season record for games played (36)" and started all 36 games..
In 2007-2008 he started every game and set the all time Butler record by having "Played in 103 consecutive games for the Bulldogs"
Anyway - on the 6th year thing...
In Betko's sophomore year at Clemson (03-04), he hurt his knee after only playing a
few minutes of a single game...and this 1st injury happened at Clemson, not at Butler -
http://www.tigernet.com/view/story.do?id=2907
..then he sat out all of that year, and the entire next year as well recovering from the knee -
In the interval - he transferred to Butler but the NCAA ruled that both years, 03-04 and 04-05, would have been lost to injury...thus granting him 3 more at Butler.
In the only other case I know of - that we have discussed previously, there was also an injury in the same year of the transfer...but...
In Lathan's case -- it appears there is NO such situation -- just the voluntary transfer in a season that he would have otherwise been eligible...
All I am saying is that virtually none of the 6th year waivers granted by NCAA involve losing a season with a voluntary transfer - and their own rules explain why...
http://bradleyfans.com/vb/showpost.php?p=101445&postcount=22